SCALING · CMO · P&L

Why top marketers often struggle with scaling

The CMO's seat is the most short-lived in the C-suite. One reason top marketers so often struggle with scaling: when a company moves from growth to scale, it is not only the amount of work that changes but its nature, and with it what is required of the CMO. The skills that helped at the growth stage can work against you at the next one.

This piece was first published in Russian in AdIndex. Below is an extended version for readers of this site.

According to Spencer Stuart, a CMO stays in the role for about four years on average, less than any other C-level executive.¹ Changing roles at different stages of a company's life may be one of the reasons. What follows is about how to get through that transition without losing effectiveness.


One person, or a change of leader

Growth rewards the go-getter. Launching from scratch, pushing things through, striking deals, quickly assembling channels, finding the breakthrough: this is about communication, energy and a willingness to go where nothing exists yet. Scale rewards something else: hard skills, established processes, cross-functional work and the ability to calmly improve results by fractions of a percent.

The trouble is that a marketer who is strong at one is often not as good at the other. For a standout specialist, the breakthrough comes easily, while methodical optimisation is boring and harder going: running a machine that already works is less exciting than building a new one. The harder optimisation becomes, the more the hard skills matter: technical expertise, analytics and discipline.

And this is where the tug-of-war begins between what you want to do and what the business needs.

Hence the temptation to solve the problem the simple way: find a different person for the new stage. I disagree, although people differ. A leader who is open to new things can get through both stages. Their key task will be to expand, not to remake themselves. This is not about changing your character or temperament; that cannot be done by order anyway.

It is about taking on new areas of responsibility on top of your previous role: where you used to negotiate and launch things yourself, you now build a regular process and learn to require the right metric from your team instead of being personally heroic.

A lot depends on personal disposition. Someone may have a natural pull towards launching in chaos: they are comfortable when "there is nothing, it has to be built" and miserable when "everything is there, it has to be improved". Or the pull may run the other way, towards order and the careful improvement of what already works. I call these two modes breakthrough and routine, but behind them is an innate inclination, not willpower. It is not a question of who is better, introvert or extrovert, but of what a person naturally gravitates towards. There are rare people who are equally comfortable launching and optimising, but there are few of them, and you cannot build a talent strategy around them.

An example from my own experience at Uzum. At the start, the task was to build the structure from scratch through communication and negotiation. Once the structure had settled, the role naturally shifted from "build it" to "own the improvement of a small, specific piece". Rebuilding the structure from scratch was no longer needed; it would have been expensive and pointless. I wrote in more detail about how we built marketing from scratch in the region in "Marketing in Central Asia".

Here it is important to be honest with yourself about whether the new role fits your disposition. If it does, you expand and move on. If it does not, that is not a reason for shame but a reason for an honest conversation with yourself and with the company. It is important to understand which competencies are your strongest and which professional tasks you enjoy most. I recommend listening to yourself from time to time and choosing the most effective role, the one that will also give you the most satisfaction.


Performance at growth, systematic management at optimisation

The difference between a top performance marketer and a systematic manager lies in where their value is concentrated.

At the growth stage it is critical to set everything up correctly from the very beginning: media buying, analytics and event tracking. Processes are written once and then change rarely, expensively and painfully. Everything a leader builds in at the start, from the analytics setup to the buying logic and the hiring system, becomes the load-bearing structure of the company for years. A specialist at this stage has to be extremely versatile, understand everything on their own and personally interview people for the key roles in the future structure. Get it wrong at the start, and the company will be dealing with the consequences for years.

The systematic manager at the next stage of the business, optimisation, solves a different problem: making sure everything runs smoothly, evenly and sustainably, and gradually extracting efficiency from a machine that is already built. Such a manager is, frankly, easier to replace, and strong people on their team can partly make up for them. This is neither worse nor better; it is simply a different function, and it must not be confused with the first one in hiring and assessment.

Comparison of stages. Growth: the question is whether it works, average CAC, D1/D7/D30 retention and 30–90-day LTV, last-click attribution, a go-getter leader. Scale: the question is what the next unit of revenue costs, incremental CAC and holdouts, LTV measured in years, incrementality and marketing mix modelling, a systematic leader
What changes in marketing as a company moves from growth to scale

Typical mistakes in the transition

When the same go-getter who launched the company in manual mode at the growth stage moves to managing through teams, they most often trip over two things.

Micromanagement. Out of inertia you keep doing the team's work, you do not let go of tasks, you check every comma and eventually burn out.

Seagull management. You fly in out of nowhere, criticise, stir everything up and fly off, leaving the team to clean up the mess.

Both patterns are equally destructive: they kill both the results and the people.


When the transition has started and you have not noticed

You cannot tell at the flick of a switch that the current organisational structure no longer holds up at scale. A good leader simply lives inside the process, as inside an organism, and senses the shift organically rather than by the calendar. You cannot wake up one day and decide that tomorrow everything should work differently.

The signal usually comes from the top: company strategy shifts towards optimisation.

And a conflict immediately follows: the top has decided to count every rouble, while everyone below wants things to stay as they were, with big budgets, fast launches and the feeling of flight. During growth the team got used to working in "give us the resources and we will deliver results" mode. At scale they are told: deliver results with the same resources. This is not an insult, it is simply a different job, but it lands hard: people feel that their familiar room for manoeuvre has been taken away, although in reality only the excess has been cut.

I will admit that for me personally optimising is more boring than growing: you have to examine results under a magnifying glass, and there are almost no breakthroughs. But that is exactly the skill of a mature marketer: not waiting for the emotional rush of a launch, but finding professional pride in squeezing out another 5% of efficiency where only yesterday it seemed the limit had been reached.


Data, the P&L and the point of restructuring

In the move from growth to scale, it is not the set of dashboards that changes but the question you answer with numbers. At growth it sounds like this: "Does it work or not?" At scale: "What does the next rouble of revenue cost?" Different questions call for different tools.

Hence the requirement for the marketer: stop being a consumer of reports. Looking at the numbers is not enough; you need to understand how attribution works: what window, what model is used to assess a channel's contribution, and what counts as organic. Without a shared language with the people responsible for data, marketing works blind and, worse, fully confident that it is right.

Growth-stage metrics

At the growth stage, simple metrics and a short planning horizon are enough. The task is to understand whether a "channel plus offer" combination pays back. For that you need to watch four indicators: customer acquisition cost (CAC) by channel and creative; cohort retention on day 1, day 7 and day 30; a proxy for customer lifetime value (LTV) over 30 and 90 days; and the time it takes a cohort to pay back its CAC.

Last-click attribution is honest here only to the extent that your media and brand contribution is small. I covered in detail how to calculate these metrics and where the logic most often breaks in "The CMO who can calculate unit economics".

Four signals that it is time for more advanced attribution

As you scale, this picture starts to fall apart: the number of touchpoints grows, some sources affect others, and some effects stop showing up in reports. The move to more advanced attribution is driven not by the calendar or by the CMO's decision but by the structure of your traffic. There are four signals.

Organic and direct traffic have passed the halfway mark. Blended CAC has started to lie: the denominator now includes people you never paid to acquire.

A noticeable share of the budget goes to channels that cannot be attributed and have no line in the attribution report at all.

The brand effect has become visible. Growth in direct searches follows media campaigns.

The cohort lives longer than the operational planning horizon. LTV is now counted in years rather than months.

Scale-stage metrics

At scale you need to move to incremental metrics, that is, to count not "how much the channel brought in according to the report" but "how much it actually added to what would have happened without it".

Average CAC gives way to incremental CAC. Now what matters is not just the cost of acquisition but the cost of a customer who would not exist without a particular channel. There is one unpleasant way to get the answer: switch the channel off in some regions for 2–4 weeks and look at the difference. A holdout group should become a regularly used tool rather than a one-off experiment: it ends the perennial arguments about attribution when you defend the budget.

Marketing mix modelling comes in alongside this, but the model needs variation, not a long history. If you have spent the same amounts for two years, it has nothing to learn from: you will first have to vary budgets deliberately through tests. And finally, retention gives way to LTV: retention tells you whether a user stayed, LTV tells you how much money they brought in over their lifetime. At scale, it is the second one you need to grow.

When to tie marketing to the P&L

The main question: at what point should you rebuild the system from cost logic to the logic of impact on the profit and loss statement (P&L)? The answer is simple: when you can no longer see the direct impact of your spending on revenue.

At the start the logic is obvious: spend 100 roubles, grow revenue by 150 roubles. During growth you develop through spending: spend more, grow more. At mature scale the same spending should deliver disproportionately more growth because you are spending more efficiently. And when revenue is measured in hundreds of millions and the difference between "spent one million" and "spent ten" is barely visible in the moment, marketing has to be tied to the P&L. I described how to build such a system in practice in "Marketing built into the P&L".


How to tell that a top marketer is not coping

The obvious answer: "The CEO does not see the value of marketing." In fact, that signal on its own means nothing. It points to a problem, but not necessarily to the marketer.

There are two possible scenarios here.

The first: the company gives marketing access to the business, to financial data, pricing decisions and product strategy. The marketer is in a position to calculate the contribution to revenue and margin and to speak to the CEO in the language of money, but does not: they live in impressions and clicks, report on reach and make no attempt to build marketing into the P&L. That is a failure, and the responsibility lies squarely with the marketer.

The second: the company itself has put marketing outside the perimeter of business decisions. It has cut marketing off from product and financial data, made it responsible for the top of the funnel and boxed it into "make us look nice". In that set-up you can bang your head against the wall all you like: no one will show you the P&L, you will not prove a contribution to margin, and "the CEO does not see the value" is not about you, it is about how the company has set up its marketing.

The failure in this situation is not the fact that the marketer's value goes unseen, but that they keep quietly doing "top of the funnel" and make no attempt to talk to the CEO about exactly where the company's set-up limits marketing. The job of a strong marketer is to point out the structural weakness in how the business has positioned marketing: to show where the system prevents marketing from influencing results, and to bring a concrete proposal for restructuring processes to the table. Sometimes they are heard, and the set-up changes. Sometimes they are not, and then the person leaves, not because they failed but because what comes next is no longer about marketing.

The statistics bear this connection out: those who stay longest in the role are the ones who speak the same language as finance, work with CAC, LTV, payback and contribution margin, and do not report on reach.² I explained why marketing should be treated as an investment rather than a cost line in "From Cost to ROI".

So I would say the real sign that a marketer is not coping is not the CEO's assessment but their own silence. A silent executor who for years keeps working on whatever they have been allowed to work on and makes no attempt to widen their sphere of influence: that is the top marketer who did not cope. Not because they could not, but because they did not try.

Which mode is closer to you, breakthrough or routine? And have you managed to switch between them without losing effectiveness?


Sources: ¹ Spencer Stuart, CMO Tenure Study (as reported by Adweek) · ² Behind the CMO, CMO Tenure Statistics


Russian version of this article: Почему топ-маркетологи часто не справляются с масштабированием


Related reading